Style and Substance

I saw this poster on the other side of the world and just knew it might come in handy somewhere.  I’ve been watching Cardinal O’Brien gaining huge media attention before and over the weekend on the subject of embryo research.  Anglican and SEC bishops – do we need to take our Holloways?

Maybe – this is a very important issue and it is clear that many MP’s – not just Catholics- are troubled by it.

I’ll offer three reflections ..

One is that many of us – myself certainly – fall into the ‘pastor -manager’ style of bishoping.  The gain is that we pay attention to the life of the church and act as leaders of mission.  The loss is that we tend not to engage prophetically with the world beyond the church as we should.

Two is that, in terms of authority, Anglican bishops are very much more collegial animals than their Catholic counterparts.  That is both strength and inhibition.

Three is that I can’t imagine myself attempting so directly to affect the actions of legislators.  Prophetic challenge to society – yes.  Direct appeal to MP’s – no and not in some of the language which has been used this weekend.

A quick trawl through the comments about the Cardinal on the BBC website reveals, as one would expect, many people who think he should stick to church-stuff and not get involved in politics.  But thinking people expect and welcome a well-argued, balanced, passionate and compassionate contribution from the churches.  We need to work harder at this.

Published
Categorised as Blog Entry

Stone-rolling

It was great in St Ninian’s this morning. Lots of light and colour and noise and music and incense and two baptisms and three confirmations and the licensing of a lay minister. We didn’t launch a ship. Nor did I see a herd of goats passing through. But I may have missed them. It was Piskie Church doing what we do well and pretending to be quite a bit bigger than we really are.

One thing I used to dislike about funerals in my former life was the death-denying material which used to creep in – ‘just slipped into the next room .. steamer being hailed on the horizon’ Sub-Christian, I think. I used to print them on the back of the Service Sheet and hope nobody paid too much attention.

No Easter faith without resurrection. No resurrection without Good Friday death. Maybe even a touch of that around in naming the decline and growth of the church.

Published
Categorised as Blog Entry

Foot of the Cross

So why would you want to remove the pews from the Cathedral?  Well – you begin to see the point when you gather around the Cross in the very middle of the Cathedral on Good Friday.  We explored the symbols – hands, water for Pilate to wash his hands, crown of thorns, thirty pieces of silver.  It’s the kind of worship that you wouldn’t have to be a churchgoer to get something out of – and surely that’s the point for a mission-facing church.

For something completely different, if you want to see what I said to the Diocesan Synod last week, it’s here

Published
Categorised as Blog Entry

Half Decade

Many subjects clamour for my attention today. I missed National Sanitation Day yesterday but I’ll give you a Bogstead update shortly. I found myself idly reading the judgement on the Paul McCartney/Heather Mills divorce last night – got about 25% of the way through the 58 pages. Dreadful stuff – no wonder she didn’t want it published. Poppy’s fan club are reporting themselves a bit starved of information so I shall prepare an in-depth interview with photographs.

But the worst of today is the fifth anniversary of the Iraq War. I was in South Africa when it started – watching Sky in hotel rooms, listening to the arrogance of ‘shock and awe’. It would be facile to say that I always knew it was wrong. I remain a fan of Robert Fisk who says in today’s Independent that ‘the only thing we ever learn is that we never learn.’ I think I can claim to have seen enough in 30 years of Irish violence to know that it is much easier to start wars than to stop them. What really does disappoint me today is to hear Gordon Brown bringing out what is essentially the ‘regime change’ justification for the war in response to a question from Nick Clegg. Yes Saddam was utterly appalling. There was a telling line in last night’s dramatic reconstruction of the debate: ‘Saddam fed people into meat grinders. If he liked you, he fed you in head first.’ But regime change was not and should not have been the justification for war – and it should not be used now retrospectively.  If Saddam, why not Mugabe?

Published
Categorised as Blog Entry

Paddy’s Day

A quick trip to Dublin to preach at the St Patrick’s Day Eucharist at St Patrick’s Cathedral. Quite an event really. The Friendly Brothers of St Patrick were inside. If you click on the link, you’ll understand why they all sounded as if they came from Perthshire – so I felt quite at home. Meanwhile outside the Cathedral was the end of the St Patrick’s Day Parade with all sorts of stuff which really belongs on Fifth Avenue, New York. We had lunch in the Deanery beneath the portrait of Dean Swift and then headed for the Phoenix Park for a Reception with the President – photo to follow later when I can get it. Last time I was there was during the July marching season with a group of Portadown Orangemen. Now that was a fascinating day! She talked about this as the first St Patrick’s Day since the formation of the new Administration in Northern Ireland. A very good quote from Ulster poet, John Hewitt: ‘We build to fill the centuries’ arrears.’

The preaching was interesting – just to get back to the mechanics of this strange art for a moment. The Service was broadcast on RTE so I was given eight minutes. I wrote a script which was 750 words – slightly more than twice what I use for a two-minute Thought for the Day on radio and about 25% more than I write for a ‘normal’ Sunday. I used seven and a half minutes. Which tells you that preaching on radio in a Cathedral is an awkward compromise between declaiming and sitting at a table talking.

Euphoria?

I know that the clergy of the SEC don’t have much reason or opportunity to give themselves to financial euphoria.  But we might find a sermon or two in a book which is being much recommended at the moment: JK Galbraith’s ‘A Short History of Financial Euphoria.’  Basically it’s the story of the euphoria which precedes the inevitable crash – and all human nature is in there – a sort of Palm Sunday and Good Friday of economics.

He suggests that there is a pattern – a mass psychosis of financial euphoria which precedes the crash.  People make money and borrow more money to make more money.  They suspend disbelief .. they acquire a vested interest in error .. vested interests rubbish any alternative thinking.  He quotes WalterBagehot, ‘People are most credulous when they are most happy.’

Interesting too the comments on leadership of financial institutions – the bureaucratic mind is predisposed to select for leadership those with the most predictable ideas and then surrounds them with others who agree and do not criticise.

Ouch!

National Cycle Route No 76

Made my springtime effort to resume cycling – beautiful day and little wind. So since I was down in Dunfermline, I left the car at the Ferrytoll and headed off down Route 76 which is the ‘Round the Forth’ route – down the back of Rosyth Dockyard and on towards Kincardine – a sort of diocesan exploration. Anyone ever been to Limekilns and Charlestown? Georgeous – think I’ll retire there. Which reminds me that an American lady in a hired Golf loomed up beside me and asked if I knew where the Rest Room was.  Maybe it was something to do with my ezy-fit lycra padded cycling shorts?  And I was even able to get an Independent in the paper shop in Limekilns. All it seemed to lack was a nice coffee shop.

Conspiracy?

I don’t think I have ever before posted a criticism of another church or church leader here.  But I can’t leave Bishop Devine’s comments on the gay community without comment.  I’ve tried to find the full text of what he said but it doesn’t seem to be posted anywhere as yet – so I am relying on reports on the BBC website.

Many things to say – but I come down to this one.

Once you start seeing people and groups who are different from you as a conspiracy, you are at risk of not being able to see them as people and respond to them with openness, love and charity.  Once you start to see people and groups who are different from you as a conspiracy, you are at risk of simply seeing them as a threat and being unable to measure, ponder and respond to what they are, what they think and what they say.

I believe that Jesus saw people and loved them as they were.  In particular, he responded to people whom others cast out.

Moral Exhortation

I am sure you have been pondering the Vatican’s  new ‘take’ on the Seven Deadly Sins.  It’s a fascinating list which includes ‘genetic modification, carrying out experiments on humans, polluting the environment, causing social injustice, causing poverty, becoming obscenely wealthy and taking drugs’

Clearly one could debate these endlessly.  The original list included envy, gluttony, greed, lust, wrath, pride and sloth.  But what is interesting, it seems to me, is how individualistic the old list was.  And now, in an individualistic age, they recast the Seven Deadlies in communal and global mode.

Published
Categorised as Blog Entry

Time of the Essence

We’re still gathering ourselves up after being away – still slapping on the moisturiser to deal with the after-effects of the sun.  Yes!  Poppy has returned from apartment-dwelling with Anna in Belfast.  She doesn’t do Easyjet – prefers travelling as a paws passenger on the Stena HSS to Stranraer.

Meanwhile I’m still pondering the preaching and sermon-surfing issues raised by the Independent on Saturday – was there ever a skill or a discipline so widely misunderstood?  I’m a believer that good communication tends to happen when there are time boundaries – broadcasting makes you that way.   So I write about 400-500 words – certainly no more.  Every word written out – and then I don’t read them.  Strange.

Meanwhile I just happened to find this handy sermon-timer doing duty at traffic lights in Bangkok.  It counts steadily down in green until your time is up.  Then it counts in red.  Every church should have one?

Published
Categorised as Blog Entry